“Transparency and Accountability Are The Main Antidotes For Corruption”


“The building sector in Anguilla is essentially lawless and unregulated. The Building Code is a long-standing joke. It exists only in the minds of shameless members of the Building Board. There are no published standards or regulations. As with Barbados, the Code is applied depending on the whim of whichever functionary you are dealing with. My fear is that it might come to be so, also, with public procurement.” … Don Mitchell at Corruption-Free Anguilla blog.

“Building Sector Lawless And Unregulated” – That Sounds Like Barbados!

On February 15th past, the Chairman of T&T’s Transparency International, Victor Hart, gave a speech to the Institute of Structural Engineers where he spoke about corruption in the procurement process of public construction projects.

It is about time that Barbados had a Transparency International chapter, but I don’t know where we would find the leaders who would stand up in public as does Mr. Hart.

Our friend Don Michell of Corruption-Free Anguilla blog has written an excellent piece on Mr. Hart’s speech and government procurement. Well worth reading.

Here are some excerpts from Corruption-Free Anguilla’s article Procurement

(Mr. Hart) reminded us that corruption damages our country by causing the undertaking of projects which are unnecessary, unreliable, dangerous and over-priced. This can lead to loss of life, misuse of funds, and resultant poverty, economic damage, and underdevelopment.

Corruption damages companies. It results in uncertainty and wasted tendering expenses. It increases project costs. It reduces project opportunities. It causes extortion and blackmail. It contributes to money laundering. It can result in criminal prosecutions, fines, blacklisting, reputation risk, and resultant job losses.

It damages individuals. It causes reduced morale, induces a sense of hopelessness in industry professionals…

Transparency and accountability are the main antidotes for corruption. It takes our architects, engineers, quantity surveyors, building, plumbing and electrical contractors, and related professionals becoming conscious of the problem. We need them to come together to join the fight against corruption. As Mr Hart points out, the advantage for them is that they will not spend time dealing with the consequences of a playing field that is not level because of corruption in the procurement process. The result will be increased peace of mind, job satisfaction, and levels of productivity and profitability.


Filed under Barbados, Business, Crime & Law, Offshore Investments

5 responses to ““Transparency and Accountability Are The Main Antidotes For Corruption”

  1. banned

    “not even the ballistics examiners could conclude which bullet, with three guns involved, actually killed Yarde, the coroner said.” Today’s Nation

    Perhaps now BFP could once again encourage a look at the RBPF and this so called Coroner’s office, the Office of Professional Responsibility, the Police Complaints Authority etc. So many complaints so little results.


    Kern caged – Politician, associates charged in bulb scandal
    published: Wednesday | February 27, 2008

    Daraine Luton, Staff Reporter

    Coleen Wright, Kern Spencer’s personal assistant and supervisor at the Petroleum Corporation of Jamaica, being led to a police vehicle after she was slapped with seven charges yesterday for her role in the Cuban light-bulb scandal. – Rudolph Brown/Chief Photographer

    DARK DAYS for former sate minister Kern Spencer began late yesterday evening when the People’s National Party (PNP) member was arrested and charged by police for his role in the controversial Cuban light-bulb project.

    Spencer spent the night in police lockup and will have to remain behind bars until Thursday, when he is booked to appear before the Corporate Area Resident Magistrate’s court. It is expected that a bail application will be made on his behalf then.

    Spencer has been slapped with seven charges. He is facing three charges of conspiracy to defraud, one charge for breaching the Prevention of Corruption Act, and three charges for breaching the Money Laundering Act.

    Also charged are Rodney Chin and Coleen Wright. Chin is facing two counts of conspiracy to defraud and two counts of breaches of the Prevention of Corruption Act.

    Wright, a supervisor at the Petroleum Corporation of Jamaica who also worked as Spencer’s personal assistant, is charged with two counts of conspiracy to defraud, one for breaching the Prevention of Corruption Act, and four money-laundering offences.

    A person who is convicted of breaching the Prevention of Corruption Act faces a fine of up to $1 million and or imprisonment of a term not exceeding two years.

    Five-year jail time

    A breach of the Money Laundering Act, which involves the transfer of property from Jamaica to overseas, of which Spencer is accused, could bring jail time of up to five years, and a fine of up to $1 million.

    Chin, 44, is the managing director of Universal Management and Development Limited and Caribbean Communications Media Network Limited. While Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP) Les Green addressed journalists on the charges last night, detectives sneaked the embattled member of parliament (MP) and Chin through a side door of the Organised Crime Investigation Division (OCID) building, all this to escape glaring camera lens.

    Earlier, Wright had been whisked out of the OCID building by police officers and taken away in a waiting service vehicle. As the police took her away, Wright hid her face with a black cloth which she later buried in her lap as she took her seat on her way to jail.

    Last night, Deborah Martin, one of Spencer’s attorneys, said they had initiated contact with the police after hearing that he had been charged.

    “We heard and we brought him in,” Martin told The Gleaner as she left the OCID building last night.

    Patrick Atkinson, Spencer’s other counsel said: “There is far too much press on this case.” He said also: “This is a witch hunt.”

    Prior to his arrest, Spencer was seen walking in downtown Kingston in the company of Martin.

    One man said that “he looked happy, waving and talking to people,” along the way.

    Spencer, 33, was the state minister in the energy ministry in the last PNP administration. His minister, Phillip Paulwell, placed him in charge of the energy-saving project. The project involved the distribution of four million free Cuban light bulbs islandwide.

    Despite the bulbs being free and Jamaica benefiting from Cuban volunteers to whom stipends were paid by their government, it racked up $276 million in expenditure.

    Since the allegations first surfaced 118 days ago, Spencer has been under tremendous pressure to resign as member of parliament for North East St. Elizabeth. Two weeks ago, he bowed to the pressure by taking leave as MP. He also took leave from all positions he had within the PNP, which seemingly has given him the cold shoulder.

    Grilled by police

    Former junior energy minister Kern Spencer walks from the offices of the Organised Crime Investigation Division in Kingston after being interrogated by senior police officers last week. He was slapped with seven charges, including money laundering yesterday. – Norman Grindley/Deputy Chief Photographer

    Spencer was grilled by police for two consecutive days last week – Thursday and Friday. The Gleaner was informed that the police were getting ready to arrest Spencer on Monday. The arrest did not take place until yesterday, after he turned up at the OCID for a third time.

    The arrest of Spencer comes after scores of interviews and the perusing of documents by the police, the Director of Public Prosecutions, as well as the auditor general and the contractor general.

    Energy Minister Clive Mullings, who 118 days ago made the disclosure about the light-bulb project, said that it raised questions of fraud. The PNP had been booted from government one month earlier, ending its 18-year reign.

    Contractor General Greg Christie found what he called a possible criminal conspiracy. He said Spencer had undue influence on the project.

    The contracts for the distribution of the bulbs were awarded by Spencer to Universal Management and Development Company, which was set up around the same time the bulb distribution project began.

    The contracts did not go to tender as required by law. Spencer has defended his decision to employ UMD, saying that an “emergency situation” existed as Cuban volunteers were in the island and no provisions had been made for them.

    Because of this emergency situation, Spencer said he turned to Chin, owner of UMD to provide the service. He said this was because he was someone with whom he was familiar.

    PNP review

    UMD’s chief principal is Sherine Shakes, the mother of Spencer’s child. Shake’s mother, Verdie Mair, was also contracted. She provided catering services.

    When the allegations unfolded, the PNP president Portia Simpson Miller had requested that Spencer and Paulwell furnish her with reports on the project.

    The details of the report have not been released but former PNP general secretary Donald Buchanan, who sat on the review committee which looked at the report, said that the party was confident that Spencer would be vindicated. His successor, Peter Bunting, said, however, that the chips should fall where they may

  3. Banned- You must have really enjoyed that CBC news coverage of our forensics department which claims we have the best technology in the Caribbean for the accurate assessment of scientific data 🙂

    Apparently it is being used most for DNA testing in paternity cases at present. (Putative dads trying to wiggle out of responsiblity for pregnancy).

    One would certainly hope that with such expertise now available to our police they would be well able to evaluate gunshot ballistics with the same certainty we read about in crime thrillers. (True sometimes a bullet is so badly misshapen they can’t say, but not often)

    But this is rather off-topic compared to Victor Hart’s brave broadside lauding transparency in public affairs.

    We have been hearing for a long time about Barbados’ Building Code. We haven’t started to see the fun and games this will cause. Much as the Chief Town Planner is praised for his general integrity, you can’t raise the subject of Planning Permission without hearing of new instances where the rules were bent.

    I fear the same will be happening with the Building Code soon enough. It will take men of steel on the committee to rule fairly and consistently on how the standards are to be applied.

  4. Gabby the "Ambassador"

    Please, can somebody kindly ask the “Cultural Ambassador”, the Mighty Gabby to be honourable and resign.

  5. Thistle

    Would Gabby understand the meaning of the word ‘honourable’??? Don’t make me laugh!