Should Peter Edey’s Business Be Given Tax Dollars Because Of His Dark Skin?
The United States and Canadian governments subsidize, support and bail out businesses all the time on the basis of the owner’s skin colour.
This morning David at Barbados Underground Blog asks whether or not Barbados should be doing the same thing.
Those of us at Barbados Free Press who are of mixed race throw in our position (somewhat tongue in cheek)…
… Perhaps the amount of government subsidy provided to businesses should be based upon a sliding scale, with lighter skin shades receiving progressively less? One of the skin colour charts worked up under the old Botha South African Government would do nicely!
That makes about as much sense as some of the policies put forward by the previous BLP government!
How Much Did BLP Race-Based Policies And Attitudes Lead Our Nation Astray?
This country was severely injured by 15 years of BLP government telling black Bajans that they needed and deserved government handouts on the basis of their skin colour. And then there was the ultimate insult – when the BLP handed out money to young black men to “help them get into business”… it bought them weed-eaters to cut the same lawns that their grandfathers cut “back in the day” as servants of the predominantly white upper classes.
There are parallels to be drawn with Noel Lynch’s “I’m just a poor little black boy” speech when he was caught out by David Ellis asking him how he became an overnight millionaire on a government salary. Never mind answering the observation about his sudden wealth, for Lynch chose the coward’s way out and said the question was racially motivated to prevent “little black boys” from ever dreaming of success. Please!
Not to mention the BLP’s history of playing the race card. Consider their election slur against the DLP that “More whites like the DLP“ or then Minister of Health Liz Thompson telling Richard Goddard that a Caucasian had no right to criticize a member of the Barbados Government.
Who could forget Prime Minister Arthur’s colourful vocabulary of words like “Negrocrat“ or the BLP agents calling David Thompson “white” and equating him with slave owners?
So what do you think, folks? Should government business subsidies be awarded on the basis the owner’s skin colour?
Join the frenzied discussion at the Barbados Underground article Black Barbadian Businesses: How Will They Fare Against Rising Competition In The Emerging New Economy?

36 Comments
April 18, 2008 at 12:57 pm
So what do you think, folks? Should government business subsidies be awarded on the basis the owner’s skin colour?
——–
Hell fricking no!
April 18, 2008 at 12:58 pm
Wonder what make and model car Mr Eddy drives?
April 18, 2008 at 1:30 pm
I ate there once and the food was OK, but nothing special and it was expensive (I think about $50 a head for lunch). When businessmen have a choice of any number of restaurants on the water (such as Champers, Waterfront Cafe or Cocomos), why would they drive into the back of some industrial estate to eat.
If his rent was $30,000 a month, he would have to sell $60,000 worth of food just to pay his rent, or more than $2000 a day.
The mistake that many black businessmen make is that as soon as they start to earn some money, they feel they need the fancy car, and the bling and the three women on the side. All of this costs money.
April 18, 2008 at 1:51 pm
BFP, that would be unconstitutional.
April 18, 2008 at 2:20 pm
no I dont think he should be bailed out. Money tight as is in the country
April 18, 2008 at 2:36 pm
$30,000 is one hell of a lot of rent to pay to open a new restaurant in that location. Peter must have known in advance where all of his business would be coming from for rent, staff, etc. etc. He must have known that he would have catering to mainly locals because that is not a spot most tourists would have gone. It is way out of the bus route, no beach, etc. I have been looking for a little place for over 4 years for the same purpose, even a rum shop type would do, and the owners are all asking around $5000, and I haven’t even bought a fork yet, LoL. What happened? Was it too much free food to friends, change of Gov’t, bad business plan, unsuitable location, living above his means? Lack of proper marketing? Looks as if it started out quite well. Anyone knows the answer to 179’s question?
It is really sad to see a black business going down, but why should the gov’t (taxpayers) assist every failing black business? How come the white ones don’t fail?
April 18, 2008 at 3:04 pm
White businesses do fail just we don’t hear about them too often as for Chief Edey a bit pathetic asking for government assistance. Have he started to cut back on unnecessary expenses yet? Is 30,000 a month the right quote? That figure alone will make me beat a hasty retreat high end or no high end.
Bajan Gobal Report
http://www.bimchat.wordpress.com
April 18, 2008 at 3:48 pm
I think he also owes money to NIS if I remember the article in the paper correctly. Deducting money from employees wages and not remitting it is theft, pure and simple.
April 18, 2008 at 5:05 pm
Barbados is doomed…If articles like this become the norm the country cannot hold its self together…
**************
BFP says,
If Barbados can be doomed by a simple website, just think of the damage a government with no rules of integrity and conduct could do!
April 18, 2008 at 5:37 pm
Many many businesses fail because the proprietor has no business sense. The man in question may be a great chef (I really don’t know, can’t afford to eat out in restuarants on this tourist island) but that does not automatically translate into being a good business man. In fact, a good business man who is a bad chef will more likely prosper than a good chef who is a bad business man. Get some proper business training, it’s available and it only requires getting rid of the local sense of entitlement that states that simply because one is a darkly complected Bajan he or she is inherently “excellent”!
April 18, 2008 at 8:12 pm
It seems as though the BLP has thrown Mr. EDEY through the EDDOES !
Just shows the dangers of lenghty SUBSIDIES !
April 18, 2008 at 8:36 pm
I feel for Mr. Edey but tough luck dude. In a place such as this I am sure you can do much better than at Manor Lodge, I quite agree with Bajan Boy. If you are going to pay 30,000 a month for a location at least let it be a good one!
April 18, 2008 at 8:57 pm
I am familiar with Mr Edey’s face but not with this particular story.Therefore the question i would like to ask is,did he while requesting this bail-out make mention of his ethnic or racial component as a premise?And what logic can be ratified by imparting your racial composition to afro-barbadians who from what i’ve read are mostly mixed if you want to use the colluqial race.Negative thinking undermines any forward thinking society .I have read alot of excellent post from this site but this story comes of as aloof and somewhat elitist and your racial barbs make you seem somehow idiotic when the pseudo-science of race is called into question.
April 18, 2008 at 9:30 pm
I worked for Industry Canada for 25 years and not during one of those were subsidies granted to businesses on skin colour. Get real people. All businesses applying for grants and contributions or loans go through a rigourous analysis as to viability. There are different programs for different sizes of businesses and according to industrial sectors. You making fun most Canadian businesses requiring subsidies are publicly traded corporations. Sole proprietorships have the SBLA and provincial incentives.
April 18, 2008 at 10:16 pm
Pat says “I worked for Industry Canada for 25 years and not during one of those were subsidies granted to businesses on skin colour.”
Ontario cultural grants
Friday, July 27, 2007 | 08:20 AM ET
Ontario’s minister of citizenship and immigration has quit after an auditor general’s report slammed the government for doling out $32 million in year-end grants to ethnic groups, without any accountability.
Only in Canada eh?
April 18, 2008 at 10:32 pm
First Nations in Canada (“Indians” to you people) get business grants all the time based upon native status. No tuition for university either.
But only for those who meet the racial purity test. Too much white in you and your kids don’t have status any more.
April 18, 2008 at 10:36 pm
Hants
April 18, 2008 at 10:16 pm
Pat says “I worked for Industry Canada for 25 years and not during one of those were subsidies granted to businesses on skin colour.”
Ontario cultural grants
Friday, July 27, 2007 | 08:20 AM ET
Ontario’s minister of citizenship and immigration has quit after an auditor general’s report slammed the government for doling out $32 million in year-end grants to ethnic groups, without any accountability.
Only in Canada eh?
++++++++++++++++++
Hants those were not subsidies. They were grants to ethnic groups for things such are cultural festivals, native language lessons, cricket, etc. Those programs at the provincial level, mirror what Multiculturalism Canada used to give out to other groups like Caribana, Carifest, Greekfest, Italian Week, etc. Those are non-profit organizations and NOT businesses.
April 18, 2008 at 10:48 pm
I sawin the new article that the business had a gross income of over $6 million and they complain about $30K per mth in rent…check the owners/directors personal acquisitions during the past five years and ask them to explain…should government have bailed what was once a highly successful Steve’s Drycleaning which had secured a profitable niche market after all the hotels stopped doing their own laundry?…what did Boo Rudder and company do with all that money…how is that that these “poor, black business” can drive about in new BMW SUVs and have five bedroom houses with solid gold bathroom fittings and swimming pool; basketball court; etc? …and they want bail out? ask Neville Rowe how he got where he ended up after being so highly successful and envied across the entire region….the piss poor newspapers do not publish what is behind these failed businesses…how come Tom Grant never responded to the charge that he/his company was paid almost $1 million by Virgin Atlantic that supposedly dissapeared with the help of a bank manager?…and every one cried “unfaired poor, black man” when the banks and NIS stepped in…..black businessmen must learn how to grow a successful business and what “retained earnings” mean to a business’ssustained development.
April 19, 2008 at 12:09 am
Slug: you real acid, man, and rightly so. I love it when people tell it like it is.
April 19, 2008 at 4:14 am
The BLP government gone and now eddey in trouble.
April 19, 2008 at 5:29 am
Lady Anon
April 18, 2008 at 12:57 pm
So what do you think, folks? Should government business subsidies be awarded on the basis the owner’s skin colour?
——–
Hell fricking yeah!
April 19, 2008 at 5:32 am
Bajanboy
The mistake that many black businessmen make is that as soon as they start to earn some money, they feel they need the fancy car, and the bling and the three women on the side.
Like Indians like me and white people too. It’s a man thing friend.
April 19, 2008 at 11:52 am
I understand that there were a few successful businesses that failed because of the south coast sewage project. . asking the government for help was a waste of time. . . even though money had been put aside for that express purpose. . .
Is this true?
April 19, 2008 at 12:17 pm
One can not assume that all Black business fail because of bad spending habits.
Most of the time it is because we fail to support our own peoples ventures,we are still vey much the product of a slave mentally THAT t states that black folk should not be self employed.
Most black business start at a disadvantage of undercapitalization and are not supported by the banking sector in rough times.
We ARE VERY MUCH BLINDED BY THE REALITIES!
April 19, 2008 at 12:18 pm
Dear Mr Government
Can you bail me out? I cannot pay my loans…
April 19, 2008 at 1:13 pm
Lady Anon
April 18, 2008 at 12:57 pm
So what do you think, folks? Should government business subsidies be awarded on the basis the owner’s skin colour?
———————————————————–
Not one red cent based on colour or any criteria.
Let the market decide.
April 19, 2008 at 1:36 pm
one for democracy
April 19, 2008 at 12:17 pm
One can not assume that all Black business fail because of bad spending habits.
————————————————————
Of course all don’t. Businesses of all races fail for myriad reasons. Some of the most successful enrepeneurs have failures and later success and vice versa. Going into business is a risk. Some succeed some fail.
——————————————————–
one for democracy
April 19, 2008 at 12:17 pm
Most of the time it is because we fail to support our own peoples ventures,we are still vey much the product of a slave mentally THAT t states that black folk should not be self employed.
Most black business start at a disadvantage of undercapitalization and are not supported by the banking sector in rough times.
We ARE VERY MUCH BLINDED BY THE REALITIES!
———————————————————-
What drivel. Did Budge Buy/Care Mart fail because we (our own people) failed to support it? Does the principal owner of that said business not own prime real estate all over this fair land?
Did Julie N fail because we did not support Nevillle Rowe or did he tie up too much funds in way too many containers of direct imports which required advance payments and consequently caused a cash flow problem?
Did he build an expensive monument at Haggatt Hall when the supermarket business all over the world is one of high volumes and low margins carried out in a warehouse type building? Did Pricesmart come here and build an eddifice?
Cash flow is the life blood of business. Take too much cash out of a business for BMW, big house etc and you cannot pay your creditors your buisness is going to fail, whether you are black, blue, red or green.
April 19, 2008 at 5:52 pm
Absolutely NO! We are human beings whose blood color is the same. It peeves me to fill out a form that asks “What is your nationality”? Or in America the first question usually is “Where are you from”? I am a human being with feelings like anyone else!!!
April 20, 2008 at 12:33 am
If I did not know anything about Barbados and I was reading these posts I would not assume that the demographics are
Black 90%, White 4%, Asian and mixed 6%
April 20, 2008 at 6:40 am
I hear all the time about cash happy businessmen who have multiple outside women on whom they shower plenty cash. How come in 40+ years of looking I have not been able to find even one of these cash happy generous men? I looking in all the wrong places? Should I keep on looking? Do cash happy business men really hand out nuff, nuff cash to outside women or is that a myth, like the white peole are better business men myth.
April 20, 2008 at 5:01 pm
one for democracy
April 19, 2008 at 12:17 pm
One can not assume that all Black business fail because of bad spending habits.
——————————————-
Just an innocent question? Can it also be that many black business (as do many business in Barbados) also have a significant problem with maintaining quality product standards and service. In the case of this particular restaurant in Manor Lodge, I have been there a couple of times and the service was fine, but the food was not even just ok, it was not at all tasty. But I do sympathise with Mr. Edey, not because he is black, but because another Bajan has not been able to fulfill his potential.
April 20, 2008 at 8:22 pm
There is a comment above about banks not providing support to “black” businesses…that is a lot of hogwash…I am a Black Barbadian with two business who has been given tremendous support by my bankers whom I do not know personally and whose principal requirement other than collateral was that I account for every cent going into and out of the business as well as that I pay myself a fixed salary like the other employees…the businesses have exceed the overdraft limits several times and we have never had a bounced cheque because of our business relationship with the bank…
However, let me share some different scenes : Muhammed Nassar a.k.a Gary Husbands was given ALL the money he required by the Barbados Development Bank to run and finance Husbands Wrought Iron & Enginering Work (as much as $5 million)..he had the first Cadillac in Barbados and he had the first yacht in Barbados (before Barrow and Furgusson) which used to be parked opposite what is now Waterfont Cafe…in addition to blowing money on plenty women he could not sexually satisfy, the idiot brought Louis Farrakhan to Barbados, opened a branch of The Nation of Islam which resulted in Farrakhan fleecing every cent he had…that is why Gary Husbands is now driving a Skoda when he had the potential to have become the “Bill Gates” of the Caribbean.
…the next one is Trevor Clarke whose business Winifred Enterprises was also heavily financed by the defunct Barbados Development Bank…like Nassar, he squandered all the money and both business ended in receivership….someone should interview Dr. Grenville Phillips (Snr)..he was the Receiver…All the money Less Frills Supermatket made was GAMBLED out…the CEO used to take the cash from the cashiers and give them IOU slips….Eddy Grant foolishly bought into the business and refurbished the branch on the Harbour Road among other things…his money was also GAMBLED out and Eggy Grant lost his entire investment when the business finally closed…
…I could go on until the next century with similar or more detailed stories…ALL of these mentioned business were very supported by BLACK Bajan consumers……
April 20, 2008 at 11:21 pm
The question is: How long does an owner realistically aim for the company to last?
Some say a company is designed to entertain the owner.
This blog title is designed to be provocative, and we rise to it.
If it is run as an extension of one owner’s personnal weaknesses then it will fail. Those whose companies fail almost always expected them to do so. Be strong, frugal, and then succeed.
If a company is created to be sustainable it can last. We all know that, it’s obvious.
Many choose to defraud and to remunerate the self, lacking mastery of the self. Local, foreigner, black, white, other; we have seen the NIS after non-black hoteliers who owed millions.
It’s neither honest, nor sustainable. We all know this.
So choose life for yours and then prosper by the sweat of the brow.
How long do you expect yours to last?
April 25, 2008 at 6:42 pm
Race based ‘benefits’ such as this one under discussion are a tricky thing. We know that colleges in the States have a racial ratio quota so to speak that they seek to fill and therefore in some cases it may be easier for a student of black skin ethnicity to get certain scholarships than one of white skin.
I can’t say im really knowledgeble about many or any other situations like that where colour either gives or takes an edge.
Of course all this originates to try and even the playing field that was made horrible uneven from our collective history of slavery – and it makes sense.
The problem is that there is no scale to hold up and say ok ..now it’s fair.. now we’ve made an even playing field and its up to the INDIVIDUAL regardless of race, class etc to make what they can of it.
The question is there.. where does it stop?
because in all reality – As a young white woman in Barbados – I could try setting up a business in Barbados and have as much trouble or sucess as my black neighboor, to the left right, across the street, as my black friends and classmates at college.
But depending on our Governments point of view could be put at a disadvantage because my parents happen to be white and I popped out white too.
Its not an issue of colour. It saddens me alot when i read the race debates on here.
There are I am sure many injustices in Barbados financially. But we need to take off the race lenses we look through and we may see that some of what we view as down to the colour of skin isnt that at all..
im rambling tho.. chya.
May 3, 2008 at 10:47 am
Although, late to this discussion and not having, yet, read the contributions, I’m fully in favour of the government or anybody else, helping to bail-out any business which is thougt to would produce a viable, workable enterprise in the medium or long term, especially, if the owners were black, brown or white because businesses provide jobs, goods and/or services and grow our economy!!
To me the question is a ‘no-brainer’ i.e. the answer is obviously, “Yes”!
May 4, 2008 at 7:35 pm
Not on race, but on viability.
If a business is VIABLE for all concerned, then help it out, not only with money, but with KNOWLEDGE! That way, everyone benefits!